From the Positivist to the Hermeneutic University: Restoring the place of meaning and liberal learning in higher education
Mackler S.
2010
Policy Futures in Education
4
10.2304/pfie.2010.8.2.177
This article argues that the university must shift from a positivist model, which emphasizes knowledge production and job training, to a hermeneutic one, which emphasizes understanding and meaning. Such a shift would be a response to two interrelated problems. First, the university suffers from an identity crisis in that it no longer holds a monopoly on the production and dissemination of knowledge. Second, Western culture at large suffers from a crisis of meaning both in a visceral sense and in the use of language to express meaning. Both of these crises are related to the increasing access to information and globalization. This article endeavors primarily to understand and assess these interrelated crises, but it also concludes with preliminary suggestions for how to begin to think about reformulating higher learning in hermeneutic terms.
Allan G., Rethinking College Education, (1997); Arendt H., The Human Condition, (1958); Arendt H., The Life of the Mind, (1978); Arendt H., Eichmann in Jerusalem: a report on the banality of evil, (1994); Barnett R., The Limits of Competence: knowledge, higher education, and society, (1994); Bloom A., Closing of the American Mind, (1987); Bok D., Universities in the Marketplace: the commercialization of higher education, (2004); Damrosch D., We Scholars: changing the culture of the university, (1995); Eliot T.S., The Rock, (1934); Gadamer H.-G., Truth and Method, (1998); Jaspers K., (1959); Kerr C., The Uses of the University, (1966); Lyotard J.-F., The Differend: phrases in dispute, 46, (1984); MacIntyre A., Three Rivals Version of Moral Enquiry, (1990); Mackler S., Learning to Live Well: re-exploring the connections between philosophy and education, Philosophy of Education 2004, pp. 296-303, (2004); Mackler S., Educating for Meaning in an Era of Banality, Philosophy of Education 2007, pp. 212-220, (2007); Mackler S., Spiritual Exercises for the Global Era: from the hermeneutic to the positivist university, Paideia: education in the global era, 2, (2008); Mackler S., Learning for Meaning's Sake: toward the hermeneutic university, (2009); Oakeshott M., The Voice of Liberal Learning, (2001); Ortega y Gasset J., Mission of the University, (2001); Ostovich S., Dewey, Habermas, and the University in Society, Educational Theory, 45, 4, pp. 465-477, (1995); Ricoeur P., Freud and Philosophy: an essay on interpretation, (1970); Rorty R., Contingency, Irony, and Solidarity, (1989); Schaffer E., The University in Service to Technocracy, Educational Theory, 30, 1, pp. 47-52, (1980); Schaffer E., The Protestant Ideology of the American University: past and future prospects, Educational Theory, 40, 1, pp. 19-33, (1990); Shils E., The Calling of Education: the academic ethic and other essays on higher education, (1997); Sommerville C.J., The Decline of the Secular University, (2006); Skyes C.J., Profscam: professors and the demise of higher education, (1988); Taves M., The New Fragmentation in Higher Education, Telos, 111, pp. 55-61, (1998); Taylor C., Sources of the Self: the making of modern identity, (1989); Weber M., Science as a Vocation, From Max Weber: essays in sociology, (1958); Wilshire B., The Moral Collapse of the University: professionalism, purity, and alienation, (1990)
Article
All Open Access; Bronze Open Access
Scopus