Liberal Arts Skills, Psychology Baccalaureates, and First-Year Employment: Notes on a Meritocracy Hypothesis
Rajecki D.W.; Borden V.M.H.
2010
Teaching of Psychology
6
10.1080/00986283.2010.488550
Selections from the career counseling literature indicated that the undergraduate psychology curriculum is a potential source of generic liberal arts skills—for example, numeracy, literacy, critical thinking—said to be useful to baccalaureates entering the workforce. A “meritocracy hypothesis†stated that psychology and other liberal arts graduates having comparatively high levels of such skills should obtain relatively more desirable first-year-out employment. Alumni survey responses from a university sample (c. 2003–2006, N = 305) served to test the hypothesis, but revealed only weak and inconsistent support. Discussion touched on issues of adequate research design regarding the impact of acquired skills on employment outcomes, and the implications of accountability measures for improved career advising. © 2010, Society for the Teaching of Psychology. All rights reserved.
APA guidelines for the undergraduate psychology major, (2007); Appleby D., Job skills valued by employers who interview psychology majors, Eye on Psi Chi, 4, 3, (2000); Liberal education outcomes: A preliminary report on student achievement in college, (2005); Aubrecht L., What can you do with a BA in psychology?, Eye on Psi Chi, 5, 2, pp. 29-31, (2001); Beins B., What should psychology majors know and what should they be able to do?, Eye on Psi Chi, 7, 3, pp. 38-39, (2003); Assessing and accounting for student learning: Beyond the Spellings Commission. New directions for institutional research, (2008); Cannon J.B., Career planning opportunities: The bachelor's degree in psychology, Eye on Psi Chi, 9, 3, pp. 26-28, (2005); Carroll J.L., Shmidt J.L., Sorensen R., Careers in psychology: Or what can I do with a bachelor's degree, Psychological Reports, 71, pp. 1151-1154, (1992); Colander D., Economics is the “just right” liberal-arts major, The Chronicle of Higher Education, (2009); Crosby O., Degrees to dollars: Earnings of college graduates in 1998, Occupational Outlook Quarterly, (2000); Fried C.B., Johanson J.C., Curriculum review using a knowledge, skills, and abilities-based assessment of alumni, Teaching of Psychology, 30, pp. 316-318, (2003); Gehlhaus D., What can I do with my liberal arts degree?, Occupational Outlook Quarterly Online, 51, 4, (2007); Graham S.E., Developing student outcomes for the psychology major: An assessment-as-learning framework, Current Directions in Psychological Science, 7, pp. 165-170, (1998); Halonen J.S., Bosack T., Clay S., McCarthy M., A rubric for learning, teaching, and assessing scientific inquiry in psychology, Teaching of Psychology, 30, pp. 196-208, (2003); Halpern D.F., Assessing student outcomes for psychology majors, Teaching of Psychology, 15, pp. 181-186, (1988); Hayes N., The distinctive skills of a psychology graduate, APA Monitor, (1997); Holland J.L., Exploring careers with a typology: What we have learned and some new directions, American Psychologist, 51, pp. 397-406, (1996); Knotts H.G., Rethinking liberal arts skills in the new economy, NACADA Journal, 22, pp. 26-31, (2002); Korn J.H., Nodine B.F., Facts and questions concerning career training of the psychology major, Teaching of Psychology, 2, pp. 117-119, (1975); Korn P.R., An undergraduate helping skills course: Skill development and career education, Teaching of Psychology, 7, pp. 153-156, (1980); Kristof-Brown A.L., Zimmerman R.D., Johnson E.C., Consequences of individuals' fit at work: A meta-analysis of person—job, person—organization, person—group, and person—supervisor fit, Personnel Psychology, 58, pp. 281-342, (2005); Kruger D.J., Zechmeister E.B., A skills-experience inventory for the undergraduate psychology major, Teaching of Psychology, 28, pp. 249-253, (2001); Landrum R.E., Finding jobs with a psychology bachelor's degree: Expert advice for launching your career, (2009); Landrum R.E., Harrold R., What employers want from psychology graduates, Teaching of Psychology, 30, pp. 131-133, (2003); Levy J., Burton G., Mickler S., Vigorito M., A curriculum matrix for psychology program review, Teaching of Psychology, 26, pp. 291-294, (1999); Lorig B.T., Undergraduate research in psychology: Skills to take to work, Council on Undergraduate Research Quarterly, 16, pp. 145-149, (1996); McGovern T.V., Furumoto L., Halpern D.F., Kimble G.A., McKeachie W.J., Liberal education, study in depth, and the arts and sciences major—Psychology, American Psychologist, 46, pp. 598-605, (1991); Morgan B.L., Korschgen A.J., How do I maximize my chances of getting a good job with an undergraduate psychology degree?, Eye on Psi Chi, 3, 1, pp. 27-28, (1998); Student engagement: Pathways to collegiate success, (2004); Pike G.R., The relationship between self reports of college experiences and achievement test scores, Research in Higher Education, 36, pp. 1-21, (1995); Pryor J.H., Hurtado S., Saenz V.B., Santos J.L., Korn W.S., The American freshman: Forty year trends, (2007); Rajecki D.W., Liberal arts skills: Weak connections with career concerns at commencement, Teaching Forum, (2005); Schultheiss D.E.P., Psychology as a major: Is it right for me and what can I do with my degree?, (2008); Silvia P.J., Delaney P.F., Marcovitch S., What psychology majors could (and should) be doing: An informal guide to research experience and professional skills, (2009); Sleigh M.J., Ritzer D.R., Undergraduate research experience: Preparation for the job market, Eye on Psi Chi, 11, 3, pp. 27-30, (2007); Stringer T.T., Four years after graduation: The class of 1993, Occupational Outlook Quarterly, 44, pp. 17-29, (2000); Titley R.W., Whatever happened to the class of ?67? Psychology baccalaureate holders one, five, and ten years after graduation, American Psychologist, 33, pp. 1094-1098, (1978)
Article
Scopus